I've never seen any Eye of Sauron cosplay before, and now I can see why: that shit's not easy to pull off. Thankfully, Captain Flameface here was up to the challenge. Not gonna lie, I thought he was the Cowardly Lion at first. Also, Saruman looks like she's ten, tops.
UPDATE: I actually managed to find some other Eye of Sauron cosplay shots and added them after the jump. They're, uh, even worse. "Impossible!" Ha, just wait.
Thanks to Jesse and dink, who considered making ears and nose of Sauron costumes one Halloween before opting for Mr. Potato Head parts instead. I call the mouth!